IdiomFood & DrinkEnglish

pie in the sky

Meaning: Something that is unrealistic or that cannot be achieved.

Example: “A four-day week sounds nice, but at this company it's pie in the sky.”

Other ways to say this

See all 3 languages side by side →

Origin: Coined outright by labor activist and songwriter Joe Hill in his 1911 song "The Preacher and the Slave," written for the Industrial Workers of the World. The song is a direct parody of the 1868 Salvation Army hymn "In the Sweet By-and-By," and Hill's lyric mocks preachers who promised suffering workers a reward in heaven instead of better conditions on earth: "You will eat, bye and bye, / In that glorious land above the sky; / Work and pray, live on hay, / You'll get pie in the sky when you die." The phrase kept Hill's original edge of skepticism as it spread — a pie in the sky is a reward too distant and too convenient to trust.

More English idioms

Explore another collection: Untranslatable Words

Words that capture a feeling or idea English needs a whole sentence for.

  • Jeong A deep emotional bond that forms slowly over time through shared experience — the invisib…
  • Forelsket The overwhelming, almost dizzy euphoria of falling in love — that specific state of early…
  • Friluftsliv The philosophy and practice of spending time outdoors — not as exercise or sport, but as…

Browse all untranslatable words →

Keep exploring

Explore all idioms →