IdiomThe AbsurdFrenchCrude

Si ma tante en avait, ce serait mon oncle

Meaning: A mocking retort to pointless speculation: with enough "ifs," anything is possible, so the hypothesis is worthless.

Literally: If my aunt had some, she'd be my uncle

Example: “« Si on avait pris l'autre route, on serait arrivés à l'heure. — Oui, et si ma tante en avait, ce serait mon oncle. »” — "If we'd taken the other road, we'd have been on time." "Sure, and if ifs and buts were candy and nuts, we'd all have a merry Christmas."

English equivalent: If ifs and buts were candy and nuts

Equivalents in other languages

Origin: A bawdy piece of folk logic: the unspoken "en" refers to male genitals, so the aunt would indeed be an uncle. It is used to shoot down arguments built on "si…" — the same job done by the milder "avec des si, on mettrait Paris en bouteille." The joke has close counterparts in other languages, including the English "if my aunt had balls, she'd be my uncle" and the Italian "se mia nonna avesse le ruote, sarebbe una carriola." Its date and first appearance are not documented.

More French idioms

Explore another collection: Proverbs

Short sayings of timeless wisdom from more than 50 cultures, each with its meaning and origin.

Browse all proverbs →

Keep exploring

Explore all idioms →